Where is your store located?

You can find our boot boutique in the remarkable bluff country of Northeast Iowa.  Heralded for undeniable scenic beauty, Winneshiek County and Decorah also offer a plethora of things to do, see and experience.  Our immediate surrounding area, Water Street, includes numerous bars and restaurants, several art galleries/frame shops, a handful of coffee shops, numerous gift/floral shops, a bridal shop, several jewelry stores, plentiful salons, a number of clothing boutiques, and a picturesque park in the town square.  Broker Leather, in its 100+-year-old building boasting with character, will be nestled right in the heart of this energetic, Norwegian-loving downtown.

Broker Leather [Boot Boutique & Leather Goods]
101 East Water Street
Decorah, Iowa 52101

What are your hours in-store?

In-Store Hours:
TUE: 10-5
WED: 10-5
THUR: 10-5
FRI: 10-5
SAT: 10-4
SUN: 11-3

What is your Return/Refund Policy?

Return Policy:

Our Return Policy [as printed on the bottom of your original receipt or on the reverse side of your packing slip] is as follows:

Refunds can be given in the initial form of payment on full-price items in the original condition [tags attached, no signs of wear and tear, free from pet hair/pet smell/cigarette smoke/stains, etc.], within 15 days [of receiving the items] when a receipt is present. Returns between 15 & 45 days meeting requirements described here will receive in-store credit for the purchase. Returns/exchanges cannot be accepted after 45 days.

To complete your return, this form must be included with the product you are returning. Any returns submitted without this accompanying form will not be eligible for a refund.

The customer is responsible for paying shipping costs for returning the goods. Shipping costs are non-refundable. If you qualify to receive a refund, the original cost of return shipping incurred by Broker Leather will be deducted from your refund. If the order was completed via Sezzle, there will be a 6% deduction from the refund to compensate the fee we paid Sezzle for your order. If you applied a discount code to complete your purchase the amount deducted will not be included in the refund and further access to that code may be revoked by the computer system.

Your refund request will be processed within 2-4 business days of receiving your package. You will be issued sufficient funds via original form of payment OR store credit via the e-mail address attached to the order, depending on the time frame of the return as described above. Store credit does not expire and can be used in-store and/or online.
Gift cards, Sale Barn items, any item sold at a discount, and all jewelry are final sale.


Sign here stating your understanding of the requirements of the return: _______________________________________________________________________________________

Please describe your reason for your return request, here: ________________________________________________________________________________________

Please print, complete, and mail this form + the product you request to return to:

Broker Leather
101 E Water Street
Decorah, Iowa 52101


 [Please right click this form below, then save image.  Then print, complete, and enclose this form with your return or use the original packing slip that came with your online order.]

What is your Exchange Policy?

Exchanges for a different size are welcome as long as we have your size available.  Please note, because we are a small boutique, our inventory changes quickly.  If the size you need to exchange for is unavailable, please refer to our return/refund policy.

What is your Hold Policy?

We love your taste and are so glad that you are grazing in our pasture!  All of the in-stock products that we feature on our website are the items that we have available to ship immediately to your doorstep. We are happy to pack up your online orders and get them to you lickety split. In an effort to keep our inventory records as accurate as possible our system can not accommodate holds or delays on shipments. We encourage you to tie down your favorite item[s] right away by placing your order online. We want you to be completely satisfied with your purchase, that being said, we offer a 14-day return policy that can be found above. For some tips and tricks about breaking in new leather boots, some handy little pointers can also be found in our FAQ.

Do you have a rewards program?

YES!  You definitely want to start earning points right away!  Here's why: you earn rewards points just for signing up, for your birthday, for referring friends, and for each purchase you make.

Our system converts your purchase dollars into points, those points build the more you purchase, and then when you have enough points you get discounts!  Your points never expire, and they just keep building!

We offer THREE discount levels for you to use your points.  The first level is $5 OFF your entire purchase, the second is $10 OFF your entire purchase, and the third is $20 OFF your entire purchase. You read correctly cowgirl, you can earn up to $20 OFF a purchase if you use our rewards program!

When you've got enough points for a discount you will receive an email from the Herd with a code to use at your online checkout! For any in-store purchases, the system will let us girls know at the register, and we will get you set up with your savings! Now that you know discounts are coming your way, saddle up and shop our pasture, pals.


Why didn't my boots come in their original box?

We take pride in recycling our boot boxes and packaging materials.  We want to do our part to take care of the environment.  Sometimes your order might not be shipped in the original box.  If your order comes in a mismatched box, we may have already recycled the original, or it was over-sized to begin with.  We will always utilize the smallest box possible to allow for priority shipping.  Thank you for understanding our recycling policy, and for doing the same once you receive your package.


Do you offer a guarantee?

Yes. We choose to offer quality boots and leather goods that are unique and trendy, well-made, and functional.  In-store and online, we demonstrate the Midwestern values of loyalty and hard work. We provide elite customer service while encouraging our customers to live by our motto: "Only Look Down To Admire Your Boots."  Please contact us with any concerns regarding your experience and/or purchase and we will do our best to reach a resolution to your satisfaction.

Why does my item look different than the one online?

The handcrafted value in the items we offer makes each one unique in color, texture, and sole.  Please contact us about the visual appeal or sole texture of your desired style and size if you have any questions prior to ordering.


How do I know what size to order?

Every brand of boot we offer is made from its own last; therefore, it has its own fit. The same goes for different styles within one company's lineup. For each individual product on our website, we try to include our best sizing recommendation within the description.  After reading and analyzing our suggestion, please keep in mind that all genuine leather will stretch with wear.  A brand new boot should fit nice and snug across the top of your foot because ALL LEATHER STRETCHES.  If you ever have questions regarding a particular style's fit, please contact us prior to ordering to eliminate the need for an exchange.  We are here to help! 


How should my new boots fit?

In a new boot, you should have roughly 1/8 inch slip in your heel and a snug feeling of the leather across the top of your foot. Through wear, the heel structure of the boot will soften and eliminate the slipping feeling, and the leather across the top of your foot will stretch and conform to the shape of your instep. It is important that a new pair of genuine leather boots be as snug to your foot as possible in order to allow them to stretch to your foot shape.

We recommend these steps to aid in getting a rigid boot on for the first time:

➴  Make sure that your feet aren't hot or swollen from a long day standing/walking. It is best to try on new boots in the morning.

➶  Wear thin socks or even nylons the first few times you wear new leather boots until they stretch and conform to your feet.

➴  Stand while using the pull tabs and pushing your foot into the boot. It should have a nice “pop” feeling once it snaps on.

➶ Twist/roll your foot to get through the instep.

➴  Work at it for a few minutes, taking breaks if you need to.

Once you have your new boots on, please remember that it will take time for leather to stretch and conform to your feet.  The softer the leather is, the more it stretches.  If you’d like to speed up the stretching process, make sure to soften the leather with a good conditioner, like Black Rock Leather & Rich. 

What's the best way to break-in new boots?

My typical break-in-period looks like this: Buy kick-ass new boots. Spray with Ariat Water & Stain Protectant. Let soak in for a day. Condition with Black Rock, wear around the house immediately while Black Rock is soaking in. I typically wear them just a few hours at a time at first until they've stretched out to conform to my foot. Usually, 3-4 wears for me. 


How do you choose names for your products?

Since all of our products are so unique we like to give them their own names. If a person or a name comes to mind immediately upon packing new merchandise that is usually the name the item is given. Other times we name products after states, towns, landmarks, horses, random thoughts we have, and other spontaneous things.


How should I care for my brand new boots?

The better you care for your boots the longer they will last! We offer a water and stain protectant spray to help keep genuine leather boots dry and mark free. Just remember that the coating of spray will wear off over time so don't forget to spray them every few months [make sure they are clean before you spray them.] We also offer and highly recommend using a good leather conditioner. Here at Broker Leather, we use Black Rock Leather & Rich. It is important to keep your boots and leather goods well conditioned and soft because if they dry out they are subject to crinkle and crack. We offer care products in store and on our website for easy access to our customers.


Can you special order boots that we’ve seen online but don’t see on your website/store?

This is dependent on the style and the brand of the boots! If the boots are from a company that we carry and have accounts with, as well as the company having them available to order we would be happy to get them in for you! Several of the genuine leather boot brands handcraft all of their styles which can take weeks, even months to create a specific boot in style, size and shipment method. Other times companies will have discontinued a style making it unavailable to us/our customers. However, if they are available we are more than happy to assist you in finding the boots of your dreams!  

Why is my hair-on-hide purse "shedding?"

Goods that feature genuine hair-on-hide may shed their fibers and change texture with wear. This is a natural effect of friction and wear, yet the quality of the leather will remain the same. We encourage you to embrace the unique qualities of your item and enjoy that it's one of a kind.

Why do my new boots have scuffs and marks on them?

Genuine leather is an impressionable material, even with the strength and longevity of the item a new boot may obtain a gentle mark or two before it finds its way to you. While we hope that your new boots have the opportunity to get roughed up on your adventures, we also know that sometimes they can arrive at your door with a “worn” look when they hit your doorstep. Not to worry, genuine leather goods will hold up through those little bumps and bruises in your everyday lives. Some of the styles we offer to our customers are already familiar-looking, where the well-loved look is intentional. Our distressed styles are meant to be just that, handcrafted and unique with their own identity – just like our herd and the companies inside our fences. Rest assured that the distressed style and the edgy vibes are meant to be there, just like our boots are meant to be on your feet.  

Liberty Black: “Unique boots for unique people.”

Corral: “…it [Corral] remains at the pinnacle of the western fashion market today, establishing a new western aesthetic: romantic, eclectic & progressive.”

Roan: “Dedicated to inspiring customers through a unique combination of quality, style and comfort, ROAN aims to provide a fierce symbol of self-expression.”


You are always welcome to contact us with additional questions 
& Remember...
Brianne and the Broker Leather Herd